As a firearms enthusiast, I have often found myself debating the merits of different calibers. One such debate that has been ongoing for decades is the comparison between the 30-30 vs 45-70 cartridges. Both are popular choices for hunting and have their own unique advantages and disadvantages.
The 30-30 cartridge, first introduced in 1895, has been a staple in the hunting community for over a century. It is a relatively lightweight cartridge that is easy to handle and has a low recoil, making it a popular choice for novice hunters. On the other hand, the 45-70 cartridge is a much larger and heavier round that packs a much bigger punch. It was originally designed for the US military in the late 1800s and has since become a favorite among big game hunters.
History of the 30-30 vs 45-70 Cartridges
The 30-30 cartridge, also known as the 30 WCF (Winchester Center Fire), was introduced by Winchester in 1895. It was one of the first cartridges designed for use in a lever-action rifle, which was a popular firearm among cowboys and sportsmen at the time. The 30-30 was a significant improvement over the black powder cartridges that were used in earlier lever-action rifles. It was a smokeless powder cartridge, which meant that it produced less smoke and fouling, and was more accurate and reliable.
The 45-70 cartridge, on the other hand, has a bit longer history. It was originally developed for use in the 1873 Springfield trapdoor rifle, which was used by the US military during the American Civil War and the Indian Wars. The 45-70 was a black powder cartridge, which meant that it produced a lot of smoke and fouling, and was not very accurate or reliable. However, it was a powerful cartridge that could take down large game and was also used in the Gatling gun.
In the late 19th century, the 45-70 cartridge was improved with the introduction of smokeless powder, which made it more accurate and reliable. It was also used in sporting rifles such as the Remington-Keene and the Remington Rolling Block. However, it was eventually overshadowed by the 30-30 cartridge, which was more versatile and easier to shoot.
The Winchester Model 1886 was the first rifle to be chambered for the 45-70 cartridge with smokeless powder. However, it was not as popular as the Model 1894 rifle, which was chambered for the 30-30 cartridge. The Model 1894 was a lightweight and compact rifle that was easy to carry and shoot, which made it popular among hunters and sportsmen.
Ballistics and Trajectory
30-30 Winchester
The 30-30 Winchester is a popular choice for deer hunting, feral hogs, and other medium-sized game. It is a rimmed cartridge, which means it has a rim that extends beyond the base of the casing. The cartridge is known for its moderate recoil and flat trajectory, making it an accurate choice for short-range shots.
The muzzle energy of the 30-30 Winchester is around 1,900 to 2,000 foot-pounds, with an effective range of around 200 yards. The bullet has a ballistic coefficient of around .250, which means it is not ideal for long-range shooting. Shot placement and penetration are crucial when using this cartridge, as it may not have the power to take down larger game at longer distances.
45-70 Government
The 45-70 Government is a powerful cartridge that is commonly used for big game hunting, including moose, black bear, and bison. It is a rimmed cartridge with a long history, originally designed for use in the Springfield Model 1873 rifle. The cartridge is known for its high muzzle energy and heavy bullet, making it an effective choice for short-range shots.
The muzzle energy of the 45-70 Government can range from 1,800 to 2,800 foot-pounds, depending on the load. It has an effective range of around 200 yards, but the heavy bullet and high muzzle energy make it ideal for taking down larger game at shorter distances. The bullet has a ballistic coefficient of around .200, which means it is not ideal for long-range shooting.
When comparing the 45-70 Government to the 30-30 Winchester, the 45-70 is a more powerful cartridge with a heavier bullet. However, it also has more recoil and may not be as accurate at longer distances. Ultimately, the choice between the two cartridges comes down to personal preference and the type of game being hunted.
Overall, both the 30-30 Winchester and 45-70 Government are effective cartridges for hunting medium to large-sized game. Shot placement and accuracy are crucial with both cartridges, and hunters should choose the cartridge that best fits their needs and preferences.
Recoil and Felt Recoil
Recoil is the backward movement of a gun when it is fired. It can be uncomfortable and even painful for some shooters, especially if they are firing a powerful round like the 45-70.
Felt recoil is the subjective experience of recoil, which can vary from person to person. It is affected by factors such as the weight of the gun, the design of the stock, and the shooter’s body size and strength.
In my experience, the 45-70 has significantly more recoil than the 30-30. This is not surprising, given that the 45-70 is a much more powerful round. However, the amount of felt recoil can also depend on the specific gun and ammunition being used.
To compare the recoil of the two rounds more objectively, I consulted a recoil chart that lists the recoil energy and velocity for various calibers. According to the chart, a 45-70 cartridge with a 405-grain bullet has a recoil energy of around 40 foot-pounds, while a 30-30 cartridge with a 150-grain bullet has a recoil energy of around 10 foot-pounds.
This means that the 45-70 has about four times the recoil energy of the 30-30. However, it’s important to note that felt recoil is not just about energy, but also about the way that energy is distributed over time. A gun with a heavy, well-designed stock may feel less recoil than a lighter gun with a poorly designed stock, even if they have the same recoil energy.
Overall, it’s clear that the 45-70 has more recoil than the 30-30. However, whether or not this is a significant factor for a particular shooter depends on their individual preferences and physical abilities.
Pros and Cons of the 30-30 vs 45-70
30-30 Winchester
The 30-30 Winchester is a popular cartridge for hunting and is known for being affordable and compact. It has been used in lever-action rifles like the Browning BLR and Savage models. The 30-30 Winchester is a capable hunting rifle and can take down medium-sized game like deer and hogs.
One of the benefits of the 30-30 Winchester is that it is a relatively mild cartridge, which makes it easy to shoot for beginners. Additionally, the recoil is manageable, which makes it a good choice for long hunting trips.
However, the 30-30 Winchester is not a powerful cartridge and may not be suitable for hunting large game or dangerous game. It also has a limited range, which can be a disadvantage for hunters who need to take shots at longer distances.
45-70 Government
The 45-70 Government is a powerful cartridge that is often used for hunting large game and dangerous game. It has been used in lever-action rifles like the Winchester 1895, Marlin 336, Marlin 1895, and Henry models. The 45-70 Government is a popular choice for hunters who need a rifle that can take down big game like bear and moose.
One of the benefits of the 45-70 Government is its power. It is a capable cartridge that can take down large game with ease. Additionally, it has a longer range than the 30-30 Winchester, which can be an advantage for hunters who need to take shots at longer distances.
However, the 45-70 Government can be expensive and difficult to find. It also has a significant recoil, which can make it difficult to shoot for beginners or hunters who are sensitive to recoil.
In summary, the 30-30 Winchester is an affordable and compact cartridge that is a good choice for hunting medium-sized game. The 45-70 Government is a powerful cartridge that is suitable for hunting large game and dangerous game, but it can be expensive and has a significant recoil.
Have you ever thought about buying ammo online?
I’m telling you it’s so easy with Lucky Gunner! The ammo shown on their site is guaranteed to be in stock and will ship fast. I heartily endorse Lucky Gunner and so do their many customers.
“Okay, so far I’ve dealt twice with LuckyGunner, and all I can say is, I LOVE YOUR COMPANY!!!!
Imagine: only items in stock are advertised. Who’da thunk, eh? The more highly advertised ones – Cheaper Than Dirt, Cabela’s, et. al. – will put you on backorder forever and a day. But LuckyGunner – I ordered 500 shells of .45 ACP (hard to get in this “shortage”) – and there it was at my address. No backorders, no bull. Business as it should be.
Yes, I’m telling my friends! I’m constantly writing down your addy on bits of paper (and running out of the latter), spreading the joyous news, “No backorders! No bull! Try LuckyGunner.com, you won’t be sorry!” Thank you for being there for an ammo-starved public. And, thanks for the SUPERB customer service.”
— Walter J., Silverdale, WA —
Jason Huskey
Owner of CCWClasses.net
Jason Huskey is a family man with three kids and a wonderful wife. He’s always starting new hobbies, but his true passion lies in shooting sports. Jason has been a CCW license holder for over 10 years and carries every day. In addition to firearms, he also enjoys playing guitar and writing songs. He tries to live by the Christian values he believes in.
More things you might enjoy…
Can a 38 Special Shoot 357 Rounds?
Image by MikeGunner from Pixabay I’ve long since discovered that very few activities give me the same thrill and sense of security as firing a gun. As a gun owner and enthusiast, I’ve always been curious about which guns can shoot which kinds of ammunition. I have a Derringer five-shot revolver that uses .22 rounds.…
Who Makes the Most Popular Brands of Ammo
If you are here to figure out who makes Herter’s ammo just look below the following table for a more thorough answer. If you are looking for a specific type of ammo, then you need to start by figuring out who makes it. There are lots of options for ammunition and each type of bullet…
What Does Full Metal Jacket Mean?
If you have heard the term full metal jacket, then you might be wondering what this means. I know that growing up, I heard this term a lot. I dismissed it as some sort of saying or cliche. Eventually, I decided that I needed to figure out what people meant when they use this term.…
How Often Should You Clean Your Gun?
After purchasing a firearm, you might wonder how often you should clean your gun. The truth is that it largely depends on how often you use it and where you live. Keep reading to learn more. How Often Should You Clean Your Gun? The short answer: do a light cleaning after every shooting session and…
What Is The Main Difference Between Centerfire And Rimfire Ammunition?
Rimfire vs Centerfire Everyone has to start somewhere. If you’re new to guns, learning the difference between rimfire and centerfire ammunition is important. Let me backtrack a moment. The first time I went out on the gun range, I had zero idea that there were different types of ammo for different types of weapons. All I knew…
Continue Reading What Is The Main Difference Between Centerfire And Rimfire Ammunition?
How Should You Hold a Handgun for Maximum Accuracy?
Whether it’s for sport or you find yourself in a defensive situation where you need to use a handgun, how you hold it will significantly affect your accuracy. Developing your handgun techniques will help you become a better shot and keep you safe. Read on to learn the answer to the question: How should you…
Continue Reading How Should You Hold a Handgun for Maximum Accuracy?
What Is Stippling On A Gun?
Hey, would you like a more firm grip on your gun? Would that help you shoot better? Well that is what stippling is for. Stippling is a modification to the grip that makes it, well, more grippy. It is done by sanding off the original finish and then using a hot soldering iron to make…
What Is A Centerfire Pistol?
To answer the question: “What Is A Centerfire Pistol?”, you must first understand that there are two main types of ammunition: Centerfire Rimfire These ammo categorizations are based on where the firing pin hits the back of the bullet to make it fire. A centerfire pistol is one where the firing pin strikes the center…
Is It Bad To Dry Fire A Glock?
There are loads of myths and assumptions surrounding handguns. If you grew up around guns, you probably heard some of these myths. Today, we will answer the question: Is it bad to dry fire a Glock. The Quick Answer Dry firing modern centerfire guns is completely fine (this includes most Glocks). The firing pin does…
What Is The Sight Picture?
When you first became interested in shooting you probably heard the terms sight picture and sight alignment being thrown around. Most people tend to use the two terms interchangeably; however, they do not mean the same thing. In this guide, I will make a clear distinction between sight picture and sight alignment. To master any new trade, you must…
What is Ball Ammo
When you hear the term “ball ammo” you may be picturing an actual ball. While the term did originate from ball shaped ammo, that’s not what it means today. Most ball ammo today is cylindrical in shape. It will have a lead core coated with copper. Keep reading to learn all about the history and…